fbpx

Good Practice at A level

By James Robinson - August 30, 2024

As artists and teachers, we cringe at the thought of 2 students in our class making an identical portfolio of work – it’s a habit at KS3, by necessity, that every student follows the same project, learning the same skills and even developing identical sketchbook pages, but surely what we really want children to do is to work beyond our starting points and introduce their own ideas. In my departments, we’ve always awarded the highest grades to those students that took responsibility for developing ideas beyond the limitations of our curriculum, whatever their age/level. In particular, we  used homework as an opportunity for students to gather ideas and images that they could use in the classroom to develop their work more independently.

Equally, independence must be at the very core of 6th form teaching. The first term of an A level course, is structured with specific skills and stimuli, but even at this point we teach them to work independently. In the dream world, every student is super-motivated with multiple capabilities, but of course, many have been pushed into the A level as an ‘extra option’, and lack either motivation or skills necessary to work without a clear structure.

However, the aim should always be to push post-16 students toward developing their own enquiries, and we specifically use the Spring term to teach this habit. The best students will already have learnt, in their GCSE exam, the value of selecting artistic stimuli as gateways to individual processes and outcomes, but this skill may need to be retaught to the less confident. A useful trick is getting the student to select two different art responses dealing with the same theme and getting them to mix them together to make a 3rd original artwork of their own. By putting the focus on artists and artworks, the teacher immediately gives control to the student, while the teacher themself becomes the guide.

To begin with, students might need a selection of stimuli to choose from, but the aim is to teach them to choose their own starting points, where possible, supported by gallery visits. We’ve always wanted to get students thinking globally and get students to imagine ‘fantasy’ round-the-globe journeys, ‘stopping off’ at 6 different destinations, using appropriate search engines to seek out contemporary artistic practice from each one. Not only does this wipe out Euro/Western bias but it lifts students out of the Picasso/Lucien Freud/Jenny Saville cliché, which examiners are very bored with!

Of course, this approach doesn’t work for everyone – some need considerably more support – but it’s the target. Almost every piece of feedback to parents should begin with ‘X is able to work independently and develop their own ideas’ – these are also the words that art colleges want to see when we write references.

Good Practice at A level – Keeping a Record

Often A level classes are taught by more than one teacher, so a useful tool we used to help develop independence was the student-teacher folder, in which both teachers record longer conversations and agree targets with the student in a weekly tutorial.

We kept the folder simple, with 3 columns enabling every student/teacher tutorial to have a clear focus, identify positives [we can all do this – weaker students might not be proud of what they’ve achieved in 7 days, but even a mess of paint and plaster was an experiment which taught the student how they can move forward] and, importantly, AGREED targets:-

Always use SMART targets (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-Bound), even specifying the amount of sketchbook pages you expect to see by an agreed date/lesson The student needs to be on board with what you expect of them. By the summer term of year 12, they should be telling you what their plans are, but if they’re really stumped, of course you’ll offer ideas. And specific agreed dates are vital – if a student has a massive French exam next week, then it’s not going to happen, but then it’s reasonable they’ll spend longer on their Art in the following week. This is a great way to record that at least one of your teaching team has had a proper conversation with every student every week – Previously, when we’d had bigger A level classes, some students got more teacher time than others. Our students valued the clarity and while targets were sometimes missed, this system really prevented any drift while allowing them to individualise their enquiry rather than doing a generic ‘homework’.

Importantly, we didn’t use this folder to grade work – nothing is more demotivating for a student developing their practice than to get any score less than ‘brilliant’. The emphasis is always upon their journey, moving forward and learning to work independently, developing their own ideas and processes.

If you enjoyed this blog post about Good Practice at A level, why not register to be kept informed about future blog posts? If you are an art teacher, you will be able to download three of the free downloads, each month too.

Enjoy this article, Drop it a like

Like

Or Share it

James Robinson

James is now semi-retired having been Head of Art and Design departments both in the UK and South Korea. A specialist in both sculpture and East Asian brush-and-ink techniques, he continues to support colleagues and teachers with hacks and solutions learnt from 25 years in the classroom. A GCSE moderator, he is also keen to share good practice that enables students to combine visual creativity with high grades.

More Posts

5 responses to “Good Practice at A level”

  1. Zoe Kyriacou says:

    A great article! Could you explain how you do the ‘fantasy’ global journeys James? The students choose their six destinations or you give them some suggestions? I’ve considered this idea, but using the main, big galleries around the world, but you’re right, encouraging the students to look beyond the obvious and discovering less well known contemporary work would be great! If you could detail your brief to the students, it would be really helpful. 🙂 Thanks!

    • Sarah says:

      A reply from James:

      I’d do it this…

      Step 1:

      ..is probably best to describe by giving my suggested script for the lesson:-

      ‘I want you to take your work on a more independent journey. We’ve worked together to develop your drawing and painting skills and I’d now like you to apply these following your own independent enquiry. At GCSE you learnt to make work in response to the work of other artists and I’d like you to go away and find between 4 and 6 artists who’s work inspires you to create something exhilarating, surprising and exciting.

      But there’s a catch – if you go looking on the internet or even in the books in our library, there is a bias towards artists coming from Europe and North America. These might include some of your and my favourite artists, but just because search engines and art institutions in Europe and the US and have the money to promote local artists, doesn’t mean we’re being given the whole story.

      Far from it – exciting, skilful and challenging art comes from all over the globe and for this project I want you to seek out something new.

      [show them a globe or a large map of the world]

      To start you off, I’d like you to devise your own fantasy trip around the world. Starting and ending in [school’s location/nearest airport], I’d like you put together an itinerary for a journey by place that circumnavigates the planet. You choose where the plane goes, but it will stop off at 6 different global destinations. None of these stopping points can be in North America or Europe.’

      activity – students assemble their itinerary;

      You will need to help some do this. Two of my schools have included students that were keen to celebrate Nigerian or Korean heritage – rather than forcing them to look elsewhere, I encouraged them to share their knowledge with students with less knowledge of these countries.

      Step 2:

      Guide students in using search engines to find out about artists from each of their destinations: I like to teach them to use a search engine that doesn’t default to AI and/or USA bias. ‘Duck duck go’ is my go to, these dates, but I just found a superb African search engine called Gushaka, which has taken me to beautiful work from Mozambique. Of course students may have access to social media and your school’s IT policy will inform how and when they can use this. Instagram is a fabulous portal to independent global art practice but the trick is to get them to type into their search engine a line such as

      ‘top 10 xxxxxxxx painters’ where the name of a country is substituted for the xxxxxxxx as it were.

      The work my GCSE Fine Art students created from typing in ‘Top 10 Iranian Photographers’, blew my mind.

      I have done this activity at the start of GCSE externally set assignments for many years and though, in mixed ability classes, there will always be children who need guidance, gone are the days of students who resort to the predictable Warhol, Picasso or even Jenny Saville and Frieda Kahlo. [yes, I know she was Mexican but look at what is coming out of the contemporary Mexican art scene these days!]

      Cubism might have come from the brains of Picasso, Braques et al, but cubism is no longer a solely European practice. Surrealism is global, and perhaps more importantly there are stunning approaches and traditions which have no equivalent in Europe and the US. East Asian Daoism revolutionised my own practice when I came across it as a teenager and continues to invigorate the practice of many of my more recent students.

      Keep it contemporary if you can – this is not about getting children to explore mud huts and primitive pots – you don’t expect students to create work from Stonehenge or Roman coins –

      I should add that I am a GCSE examiner and though my board’s aim is to see the very best from every student and award industry and talent, it’s not so easy when a child is regurgitating the same old response to Warhol, Hopper or Magritte. If they document their journey – easily done with cut and paste and simple pencil notes – they are making marks for making an individual, personal enquiry.

      Beat bias, bring originality into the classroom and show your students the world.

      Good luck.

      • Zoe Kyriacou says:

        Absolutely brilliant! Thank you so much for taking the time to write about the project in such detail. I really look forward to giving this a go!

  2. linda panattoni says:

    love this article. what a great way to motivate students.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Resources you might like...